Oatmeal Cookie

The Oatmeal Cookie cocktail is a delightful blend of flavors that mimics the comforting taste of the classic dessert.

  • 5 min
  • Easy
  • Mason jar
  • 5 ingredients
Hero bottle: Butterscotch schnapps →

Oatmeal Cookie

Ingredients

1
  • Kahlua2 parts
  • Baileys irish cream2 parts
  • Butterscotch schnapps4 parts
  • Jagermeister1 part
  • Goldschlager1/2 part

Method

  1. Just mix it all together.
  2. It's meant to be a shot, but it works just fine as a proper adult-sized drink over lots of ice.
  3. Tastes like an oatmeal cookie.
Pin it

What you need

Nothing fancy. Here is what to look for. We earn a small cut if you buy through these links, at no cost to you.

A double jigger

Marked in oz and ml, with lines inside for the small measures.

See on Amazon ↗

The hero bottle

See 4 Butterscotch schnapps drinks

Where it comes from

The Oatmeal Cookie is a dessert-inspired cocktail that emerged from the modern trend of creating drinks that emulate beloved comfort foods and nostalgic flavors. Bartenders began crafting shots and cocktails that taste like popular cookies and desserts, appealing to consumers seeking indulgent, familiar taste experiences. This drink represents the playful intersection of mixology and culinary nostalgia.

Tips from the bar

  • Use butterscotch schnapps as the primary flavor base
  • Add Irish cream for creamy texture
  • Incorporate vodka for proper spirit balance
  • Serve ice-cold for optimal taste
  • Shake well to ensure proper mixing

Twists worth trying

Premium Oatmeal Cookie
Uses craft vodka and premium cream liqueur
Spiced Oatmeal Cookie
Adds cinnamon schnapps for warm spice profile
Cream Oatmeal Cookie
Incorporates whipped cream topping for dessert presentation

What to eat with it

  • Fresh-baked oatmeal cookies
  • Cinnamon roll
  • Maple brown butter cake
  • Caramel apple
  • Honey granola
  • Pecan pralines

The finished drink

Oatmeal Cookie

Questions

What is in a Oatmeal Cookie?

A Oatmeal Cookie is made with kahlua, baileys irish cream, butterscotch schnapps, jagermeister, goldschlager.

What glass do you use for a Oatmeal Cookie?

Serve a Oatmeal Cookie in a mason jar.

What does a Oatmeal Cookie taste like?

Expect sweet, nutty, spiced.

What can I make with Butterscotch schnapps?

We have 4 drinks built around Butterscotch schnapps. See them all on the Butterscotch schnapps page.

More with Butterscotch schnapps

Every Butterscotch schnapps drink →

One good drink, every Friday.

A recipe, a trick and the bottle worth buying next. No spam, and the unsubscribe link actually works.